| Bracket | Rnd | Match |
| Winners | 1 | Will B def Ice |
| Winners | 2 | Matt G def Ryan S |
| Winners | 2 | Jason C def Alden R |
| Winners | 2 | Dave L def Will B |
| Winners | 2 | The Puppetmaster def Suzanne G |
| Winners | 3 | Matt G def Jason C |
| Winners | 3 | The Puppetmaster def Dave L |
| Winners | 4 | Matt G def The Puppetmaster |
| Losers | 1 | Ryan S def Ice (eliminated) |
| Losers | 1 | Patrick W def Suzanne G (eliminated) |
| Losers | 2 | Alden R def Ryan S (eliminated) |
| Losers | 2 | Will B def Patrick W (eliminated) |
| Losers | 3 | Dave L def Alden R (eliminated) |
| Losers | 3 | Will B def Jason C (eliminated) |
| Losers | 4 | Will B def Dave L (eliminated) |
| Losers | 5 | The Puppetmaster def Will B (3rd Place) |
| Finals | Matt G def The Puppetmaster |
| Finals | Matt G def The Puppetmaster |
